DRC: Little hope for lasting truce with M23

The US, UN and the African Union (AU) were among the first to welcome the July 19 truce  between the  Democratic Republic of Congo and the M23 rebel group, which had been championed by the US and Qatar. 

The Doha Declaration of Principles , building on a  peace deal the DRC and Rwanda  signed in Washington on June 27, was meant to serve as another "meaningful step toward advancing lasting peace and stability in the Great Lakes region," according to the US Department of State.

Rwanda's willingness to sign and its passive observation over the Doha agreement was seen as tacit admittance to its role in the long-standing conflict, although Kigali continues to deny its support of the M23.

Is the DRC a no-go zone?

Just one day after the signing in Doha, the US updated its security advisory for the DRC and especially its capital Kinshasa, advising US nationals in the country to "exercise increased awareness, avoid large gatherings, and monitor local news and security updates."

The list of recommended actions include the provision of "enough food and water should you need to stay home for several days" and having "essential items (clothing, medications, travel documents) packed in a bag that you can carry."

The advisory resembles the kind of advice US authorities give to prepare for major natural disasters.

The June 27 peace deal between the DRC and Rwanda sparked hope for the troubled region, but the deal with M23 rebels appears less promisingImage: Mark Schiefelbein/AP/dpa/picture alliance

Reagan Miviri, a conflict analyst and lawyer working with the Congo Research Group (CRG) in Kinshasa — an independent, non-profit research project — understands the importance of the US State Department's latest travel advisory. 

"The crisis in eastern Congo is also visible in Kinshasa in some ways," she told DW. "Actors in the US [who] are worried about what could happen in Kinshasa … probably know much more than we do, so perhaps they have other information we don't have." 

According to Lidewyde Berckmoes, an associate professor and senior researcher at the African Studies Centre Leiden in The Netherlands, many parts of the DRC still actively remain under the control of the M23, which is unlikely change despite this deal.

"This region has seen many violent rebel movements, who have been there since the 1990s. There are many places where there's a lot of tension, and where authority is contested," Berkmoes, whose work is focused on Africa's Great Lakes region, told DW.

M23 expansion course continues

On the ground, the reality of a state of war effectively continues to dictate daily lives in various parts of the country — especially eastern DRC's North and South Kivu provinces where, mere days after after the DRC-M23 truce was inked, fresh reports of M23 rebels seizing new ground surfaced.

According to UN-backed Radio Okapi in the DRC, at least 19 civilians were killed by M23 fighters as part of that expansion course, in particular around the village of Bukera.

This latest escalation is in clear breach of the Doha ceasefire deal, which calls on all sides in the conflict stop efforts to expand their territorial gains — among various other stipulations.

A truce with an ambiguous message

Human rights activist Philemon Ruzinge believes that the Doha deal will ultimately be of little consequence despite whatever concessions Kinshasa may commit to in order to keep the peace.

"The agreement of principles is supposed to be … so important towards a lasting peace agreement," he told DW, adding however that the ongoing actions of M23 rebels leave little hope for it to work in the long-run.

According to Ruzinge, M23 leaders feel they can continue to enjoy free reign over northeastern DRC on account of the text of the agreement "containing no withdrawal clause" and deliberately being worded in an ambiguous manner.

This view was only further solidified by the M23 itself, whose delegation leader at the signing in Doha, Benjamin Mbonimpa, reiterated that the group "will not retreat, not even by one meter." 

"We will stay where we are," Mbonimpa said.

According to the UN, about 7 million people have been displaced in the DRC due to the conflictImage: Luis Tato/AFP

Rebels trying to leverage political control

Berckmoes believes that Mbonimpa's attitude is indicative of the overall M23 position: "I don't think M23 will let themselves be sidelined. Rather, I expect that they are looking for ways to have an important say as part of the government."

Miviri agrees: "M23 are saying that they are not leaving," adding that this should be taken at face value: "M23 will do whatever it pleases."

That view is also shared by people in North Kivu province. Complaints by civil society groups about a lack of government intervention is mounting. In the province's beleaguered capital, Goma, democracy activist Justin Murutsi told DW: "The state has a security mandate for the population. But when there are killings like this and no word from the state, it shows that there's a serious institutional vacuum."

"The signing of the Declaration of Principles gives us a little hope, because it clearly shows that the government has accepted the rebels' demands and conditions," said Julien, a resident of the city who believes that M23 will remain in control of large parts of the region.

Skepticism seems to outweigh hope

Political scientist Christian Moleka in Kinshasa wonders whether the parties the conflict are interested in peace. "Do the various parties even have the will to achieve lasting peace?" he said in a DW interview. "Are the follow-up mechanisms really going to work better than in the past, to support the full implementation of these various provisions?" 

Berckmoes has similar reservations, stressing that there has been "series of agreements in the past, which have not been upheld."

She adds that for a sustainable peace plan to succeed, various parties and factions all have to be included in all negotiations — not just M23 but "all 160 groups" vying for control. To that end, Berckmoes believes "there's still a long way to go."

Miviri takes an even more sober stance: "Before speaking of a lasting peace agreement, it just has to first happen. And I'm not seeing it happen, even now."

Amid skepticism, criticism, and the surge in violence since the Doha signing, there have also been a few hopeful voices — among them, the US Senior Advisor for Africa, Massad, Boulous. 

According to DRC Interior Minister Jacquemain Shabani, significant progress has been made in recent weeks. He said he is convinced that despite the ongoing volatile nature of the conflict, "we are close to peace." In the same statement, however, he stressed that "peace is a choice," which "requires work."

Edited by: Benita van Eyssen